6 Common Payroll Tax Mistakes Small Business Make

Running a small business can be a rewarding experience, but it also often comes with a lot of additional work to make sure everything is taken care of properly. With fewer employees, it means staff often wear multiple hats and sometimes mistakes can happen. While minor mistakes don't always result in costly issues, simple mistakes in business payroll can lead to major problems. Below are six common mistakes small businesses can run into when it comes to payroll.


Improper Employee Classification

When classifying workers, they will fall into one of two main categories: employees and independent contractors. Employees and contractors are completely different when it comes to paying taxes and offering benefits. An employee of a company will often be allowed certain benefits, be able to collect overtime wages, and have their payroll taxes deducted through their paycheck which the employer will then pay to federal and state and local tax entities if applicable. 


An independent contractor is expected to report and pay their own payroll taxes and is not subject to minimum wage and overtime laws. They are not considered to be employees and will not receive benefits other employees do. Yet, if you accidentally classify your employee as a contractor, you will be required to pay back taxes for their work along with accrued penalties and interest. You may also owe back wages to your employee. 


Calculating the Wrong Overtime Wages

Overtime wages are calculated differently than your employee's regular wages. Federal law states that an employee must be paid time and a half for overtime wages or 1.5 times their regular pay. Different states may have different overtime requirements, so it is vital to stay up to date with state overtime laws as well. If you fail to pay employees their proper overtime wages, you will not only have to give them back pay for the wages they should have earned but may be required to pay penalties and interest on the back pay as well. 


Not Paying the Correct Pay Rates

Tax rates are constantly changing, and it is important to stay ahead of these changes, so you do not end up miscalculating the amount you need to pay in. Failure to pay the correct amount can result in interest and penalties that can reach immense sums. You should make sure to stay updated on payroll rates for:


  1. Federal Income Tax
  2. Social Security Tax
  3. Medicare Tax
  4. Federal Unemployment Tax
  5. State Income Tax
  6. State Unemployment Insurance Tax
  7. Local Income Tax


Processing Payroll Late

Payroll will need to be run on the pay frequency you have set. This can include weekly, bi-weekly, semimonthly, or monthly payments. Not only will failing to pay your employees on time erode their trust with you, but it will also make you non-compliant with the state pay frequency requirements. You will need to make sure your payroll is processed at the set schedule as well as in enough time for it to be completed by the pay date. If this becomes an issue, you may want to look into payroll funding for small businesses.


Not Filing Required Reporting

Your business will be required to file regular payroll reports to the various tax entities with the federal, state, and local governments. This includes quarterly reporting on wages of employees and often are accompanied by payments. You will also be required to file reports and pay additional taxes quarterly for unemployment taxes. Failure to pay these taxes or file these reports can put your business in poor standing and often incur expensive interest and penalties. 


Not Keeping Proper Records

You are required to keep and maintain payroll records of all your employees. This includes things such as hours worked, wages paid, overtime, bonuses, holiday pay, vacation pay, and sick pay. These records need to be available in the event there is a question about the employee's pay or overtime wages. You will also need to keep these records in the event a tax entity requests documentation to back up your reports and tax payments.


Avoiding the above six payroll mistakes can help reduce your risk of incurring penalties and interest for unpaid or underpaid taxes and help you maintain compliance with your state and federal regulatory bodies. Taking control of your payroll is not only important to your employees but also to your company's bottom line. 


This content is developed from sources believed to be providing accurate information. It may not be used for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties. Please consult legal or tax professionals for specific information regarding your individual situation. The opinions expressed and material provided are for general information, and should not be considered a solicitation for the purchase or sale of any security.


Recent Buttonwood Articles


Investmen
By Dale Raimann January 7, 2026
As we closed out 2025, our Investment Policy Committee (IPC) continued its work to refine strategies that balance risk, liquidity, and long-term growth. In our previous update , we shared how the inflation shock of 2022 reshaped our approach to fixed income and led to a more nimble, systematic positioning of bond assets. That proactive discipline remains a cornerstone of our investment process. As we wrapped up 2025, our Investment Policy Committee (IPC) continues efforts to refine strategies that balance risk, liquidity, and long-term growth. With the Fed reducing overnight lending rates for the third time, recent IPC discussions have turned to another critical focus area: cash management. Why Cash Strategy Matters Now With interest rates still elevated and market uncertainty persisting, many investors hold larger-than-usual cash positions. While cash provides stability, it also introduces opportunity cost if left idle. One of our IPC objectives is to ensure that excess cash works harder for you, without compromising liquidity for emergencies or near-term cash needs. Refining Our Cash Allocation Policy For our clients with larger cash needs (generally more than 5% or $50k of liquid assets in cash or money market funds), we are shifting to a proactive T-Bill management strategy, or other suitable investments based on goals and circumstances. For our clients holding less than $50k in cash or money market, we have retained money market for liquidity, but we have made a switch to the default money market fund we are using. Risk and Tax Aware Money Market Selection While yields are similar across money markets today, the underlying investments in each money market fund vary quite a bit. For example, Schwab Prime Money Market (ticker SWVXX) offers a slightly higher yield but invests in asset-backed commercial paper (ABCP), introducing a modest credit risk. In contrast, Schwab Government Money Market (ticker SNVXX), invests primarily in U.S. Treasuries and government-backed securities, making it virtually risk-free and often state income tax-advantaged. With lower risk and only about 10/100’s of 1% yield difference, our IPC has proactively transitioned clients from SWVXX to SNVXX, to prioritize safety and tax efficiency over a marginal yield difference. Connecting Back to Our Broader Strategy These cash management refinements build on the fixed income strategy we recently outlined. By reducing exposure to inflation-sensitive bonds and implementing a more systematic approach, we are positioning portfolios to be more resilient across potentially weaker or higher-rate environments. Optimizing cash allocations and minimizing credit risk within money markets reinforces the same core principle—protecting downside risk while prudently capturing incremental return opportunities. Looking Ahead As we enter 2026, our investment approach remains focused and disciplined. We continue to prioritize liquidity for cash needs, thoughtful risk management, and systematic investment strategies designed to adapt to evolving market and economic conditions. This proactive framework supports long-term portfolio resilience while remaining aligned with your financial objectives. If you have questions about how these updates may impact your investments, cash management, or overall financial plan, we encourage you to connect with your financial advisor at Buttonwood. Our team is committed to delivering personalized wealth management and asset allocation strategies—regardless of market or economic uncertainty. Thank you for your continued trust and for allowing us to coordinate your asset management as part of our Family CFO services.
How to Talk About Money with Family Over the Holidays
December 23, 2025
How to Talk About Money with Family Over the Holidays. Whether your family is just beginning to plan or has been navigating financial decisions across generations
December 12, 2025
As year-end approaches, many clients focus on charitable giving—supporting causes they care about while optimizing their tax strategy. This year carries added urgency: the One Big Beautiful Bill Act (OBBBA) will significantly change charitable giving rules in 2026.
Buttonwood Investment Policy Committee Update
By Jon McGraw November 24, 2025
Maintain diversification as one of our risk management tools, focusing on our high-conviction ideas that tie with where we feel we are in the economic cycle.
Buttonwood Investment Policy Committee Update
By Kyle Hogan September 26, 2025
Our Investment Policy Committee (IPC) remains focused on balancing opportunity with discipline as markets continue to react to shifting economic and geopolitical dynamics. Following a volatile start to the year, recent developments have created a more constructive environment for risk assets, though caution remains war
Inside the Capitol Building, where the
By Jon McGraw July 21, 2025
On July 4, 2025, President Trump signed the One Big Beautiful Bill Act into law. Learn what that means for business owners.

Are you ready to explore the benefits of your very own Family CFO?

LET'S TALK

Buttonwood Services


About Buttonwood Financial Group